Hypergraffiti

Where I spray-paint my thoughts…

Gandhi, Mandela, the Dalai Lama and Me…

11 Comments

Those are my homies, in case you were wondering.  My peeps. We hang out together … on the Political Compass.

Let me explain.

Every year about this time I have to introduce my World History students to the concepts of “left” and “right” on the political spectrum, using a handy little graphic in our textbook. Then I do the obligatory disclaimer explaining how a simple “left-right” spectrum grossly oversimplifies complex political issues, and that a somewhat broader perspective might be gained by using a tool like the Political Compass, which at least plots people’s views on two axes. I then suggest that for those really interested in this sort of thing, they might try taking the online test themselves to see where they fall.

Just for laughs, I put an X in the lower left quadrant (left-leaning political and economic views with high emphasis on individual freedoms and minimal government control) to show where I fall.  When I did this the other day I asked, “And do you know who is the only major twentieth-century historical figure down there with me?”

They all stared blankly, until the one student who took the class from me last year yelled, “GANDHI!!!!”

That’s right, me and Gandhi, kickin’ it together down in the lower left quadrant.  Like so (you can’t see me, but I’m right next to the Mahatma):

 

axeswithnames1

“And do you know why Gandhi and are down there together?” I ask them all. “Because we are both idealists.  We believe in all those socialist ideals — the rich sharing their wealth with the poor, everyone having enough to meet their needs — but we believe there’s enough goodness in human nature to achieve those things by free will, without the use of force.  Gandhi and I believe in a world where everyone freely shares with everyone else, and the unicorns and bunnies dance around happily under the rainbow….”

To be fair to Gandhi, he’s achieved a lot more with his idealism than I have with mine.  On the other hand, he got shot, and so far, that hasn’t happened to me.

Later I looked further down the page and saw another version of the compass with a whole lot more famous names on it.  Now Gandhi and I are joined by Nelson Mandela and the Dalai Lama! What cool company!

 

internationalchart

The thing is, this got me thinking. Obviously all the coolest people of the twentieth century are down in the lower-left quadrant.  Does that really reflect their political views accurately, or does it reflect the views of the people who made up the test? Maybe the test-makers are lower-lefters themselves and stacked the deck with all the coolest people they could find!

Which led me to another reflection: I truly and honestly believe if Jesus were to take the test, He would be in the lower left quadrant. Gandhi, Mandela, the Dalai Lama, Jesus, and me.  And I believe that the reason I hold those lower-leftie beliefs and try (albeit weakly, not like the big names on the list) to live by those standards, is because Jesus believed and lived those things, and I want to be like Him.

But what if I’ve got it backwards? The human capacity for creating God in our own image is endless.  Maybe those political leanings are my natural inclination, and I’ve just managed to convince myself that Jesus is just like me.  Maybe I’ve made myself a God I’m comfortable worshiping.  Maybe any sincere Christian who took the test, whichever quadrant he or she came out in, would just as sincerely believe Jesus was in that same segment of the map.

What do you think? And if you’ve taken this test, where do you find yourself on the spectrum?

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Gandhi, Mandela, the Dalai Lama and Me…

  1. Yes, I’ve taken this test and found myself to see the only one there with Gandhi – glad to see we have some company!!!

    -Patricia
    http://www.dare2beme.wordpress.com

  2. Hey Trudy, you can add me to your buddies list 🙂 I actually wasn’t sure where I’d fit because I’m a toe-the-line kind of gal when it comes to the law and authority. But apparently, you, me, Ghandi, Nelson and Jesus can all hang out together. Oh, and don’t forget the Dalia Lama. I am pushing further north than Ghandi, however…

    Thanks for sharing this. Very interesting!!

  3. Looks like I’m in the bottom left too. I’m a bit surprised by that, because I do lean right in some areas…I guess not enough areas to put me in that camp, though.

  4. I’m in the lower left too, though I’m closer to the Dalai Lama than Mandela and Gandhi

  5. Hmmm … Jason just took it and landed right on top of Gandhi. After reading everyone’s responses, I’m getting suspicious that the test really is slanted so that every half-decent human being comes out in the lower left (more right-wing half-decent human beings are welcome to take the test and prove me wrong!)

    By the way, on a totally non-political note, the FAQ on that Political Compass site has one of the funniest answers I’ve ever seen to the question, “When are you guys going to learn to spell?”

  6. I’m pretty much right smack in the middle of the left square.

  7. As an Aussie who speaks and writes the Queen’s English, I don’t see what was so funny about that answer, Trudy 🙂 I will savour the opportunity to receive a favourable review of the way I spell…hehehehe. It was very clever.

  8. Lower left for me too. I agree the test is probably tilted – I was surprised to come down as far as I did on the “lower” side – I thought I might even be just barely above the line there.

  9. I score close to you as well. And I find the more I try to follow Jesus, the more accepting I become of everyone-not just those who think like me. Though according to this, the people who think like me are pretty good company.

  10. Hello, Trudy. I too, end up very near to Dalai Lama. Any idea what does that make me ? A Social Libertarianist , or something ?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s